What is that smell?

By Geoffrey Sakala, Ranchocordovapost.com

Neighbors in Anatolia have a burning desire to rid the air of the foul stench of rotten flesh. The smell is the rendering plant on Sunrise blvd. and Kiefer.  There has been a recent spike in the frustrations with the awful odor emanating from the plant which burns road kill for Sacramento county and surrounding areas.

Angela Davy, the Sacramento Metropoitan Air Quality inspector who regularly visits the plant, is requesting that complaints about the smell be submitted either through their website at www.airquality.org programs->complaints or by calling locally 874-4800 or toll free 1-800-880-9025. According to Angela, the plant is usually not burning on Sundays for clean up, but the plant typically gets deliveries during the day and burns later from 3:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. everyday.

The Sacramento Rendering Co. has occupied its 11350 Kiefer Blvd. site since 1955, long before there were any housing developments in sight. There were 165 recorded complaints in 2007 and 23 complaints so far this year, according to air quality records. The rendering company had 23 units inspected over 11 days in 2007 and 19 units inspected so far in 2008 over eight days, according to air quality records. Seven violations were recorded in 2007, according to air quality records. The plant has had no violations in 2008.

In 2003 the builders and developers of the Anatolia sub-division filed a lawsuit in an attempt to require Sacramento Rendering Company to install costly scrubbers to reduce the smell. SRC prevailed when the lawsuit was thrown out of court based on a state law that protects agricultural processing facilities established for more than three years in the same location. The developer was also required to repay the attorney fees for Sacramento Rendering Company.

That summer Sacramento County planning officials passed a resolution that the developer could not obtain any building permits until the odor equipment was installed. This required the developer to spend $2.7 million to install scrubbers at the plant to reduce the smell. These liquid filled cylinders trap and absorb the gas produced by the burning carcasses. There is some question as to whether or not the scrubbers are being used or turned off to save on electrical costs. The estimated maintenance cost to run the scrubbers, at the time of installation, was $30,000 to $35,000 per month.

Mark Loutzenhiser, program supervisor at the air quality district, says “A lot of those things that we think of as being odors are often times flammable. So if you burn them, you can break them down from whatever their formula was into carbon dioxide so you hopefully don’t smell it.”

The Sacramento Metropolitan Air Quality Management District is the public agency responsible for monitoring the proper use of the scrubbers and imposing monetary fines for violations.  The plant has been cited in the past by SMAQMD for violations and by the Water Quality Control Board for waste spillage. In May of 2007 SRC was required to pay $20,220 in penalties for violations which occurred in 2005 & 2006. SRC failed to maintain several of their water feeds at the minimum gallons per minute (gpm), failed to operate their spray tower scrubber while rendering and failed to properly maintain flow meter equipment.

As more homes are built in Anatolia, Mather and Kavala Ranch it appears clear that plant manager Bill Eckstein knows his days on Kiefer blvd are numbered. When will the plant find a more remote location remains to be seen. It probably depends on the will of the residents and the willingness of the City of Rancho Cordova to make it happen.

Mike Linville, a resident of Anatolia has created a useful website for following the battle with the rendering plant. His website www.whatisthatsmell.net provides the ability to rate the day’s smell, follow recent developments in the news, and link to the SMAQMD complaint form.

By Wesley DeBerry, SacBee.com

Local residents continue to have complaints about a Sacramento County rendering plant, a battle that is about a decade old.

The aroma from the plant’s daily operation of recycling animal waste materials is a nuisance to some nearby residents, who have moved into new homes.

Rendering plant officials declined to comment. When the issue was first raised by developers in the early 1990s, they argued that the plant has the right to continue to operate because it was there first.

The Sacramento Rendering Co. has occupied its 11350 Kiefer Blvd. site since 1955, long before there were any housing developments in sight.

Anatolia residents Jared and Cari Ricci said they have noticed an unpleasant odor during the evening hours on average a couple of times a week.

“It’s usually gone by the morning,” Jared Ricci said.

Mather resident Nancy Sweet said the smell has lessened since she first moved to community in 2005. However, she said, a couple of times a week she will notice a foul smell.

Some residents have filed complaints with the Sacramento Metropolitan Air Quality Management District, the agency that enforces state and federal air quality standards. The rendering company does have equipment to minimize odors, officials said.

They also said they don’t expect the issue to go away anytime soon.

The plant has an oxidizer that is similar to an air purifier that heats up the fumes from plant production.

“A lot of those things that we think of as being odors are often times flammable.” said Mark Loutzenhiser, program supervisor at the air quality district. “So if you burn them, you can break them down from whatever their formula was into carbon dioxide so you hopefully don’t smell it.”

The plant also has scrubbers, to help fight odors. The scrubbers are liquid-filled cylinders in which operational gas enters and is absorbed.

Paul Niemann of Kavala Ranch moved just down the road from the rendering plant one month ago. He said he hasn’t smelled anything.

However, there were 165 recorded complaints in 2007 and 23 complaints so far this year, according to air quality records.

Loutzenhiser said the number of complaints from residents has put the plant “basically under a microscope.” On average, a normal source is inspected once a year.

But the rendering company had 23 units inspected over 11 days in in 2007 and 19 units inspected so far in 2008 over eight days, according to air quality records.

Seven violations were recorded in 2007, according to air quality records. The plant has had no violations in 2008. A single malfunctioning pressure gauge can cause a violation, officials said.

“Even if they have a permit violation, it may not mean that the process wasn’t working properly,” said Christina Ragsdale, program coordinator for the air quality district.

Despite all the regulations, inspections and complaints, a foul odor radiated near Kiefer Boulevard by the plant on Thursday evening.

“People think, ‘Why can’t you stop it from smelling?’ Well, it’s complicated,” Ragsdale said.

If you have noticed the nasty smell that blows through Anatolia with some regularity, you are not alone! That smell belongs to our local rendering plant owned and operated by Sacramento Rendering Companies. The plant is located just off of Sunrise Blvd. at Kiefer Blvd., less than 2 miles from the Anatolia master planned community [click here for map].

(more…)

One suggestion solicited by the plant’s manager Bill Eckstein is that neighbors should call him and alert him of smell, time of day etc. I was told that he wants to hear from us and do what he can to keep the smell contained. And that he leaves the plant at 3:00 pm each day.

Plant Manager Bill Eckstein: 916.363.4821